top of page
grad-purple-blue.png

Enforcement technology and public trust

Methodology

Training

Intervention

Tool

Data

Study

Use case

THINGS, based on the ELABORATOR Lighthouse and Follower city reports

Overview

The lesson in one sentence: cameras and sensors can help a city protect bus lanes, bike lanes and pavements from illegal parking, but in ELABORATOR they depended on explaining the system first, involving the police early and having the means to make partners take part.

Several ELABORATOR cities used technology to detect illegal parking or monitor compliance. Stakeholders asked for openness, the police had to be on board, and cities needed leverage over the companies involved.


Highlights

Split: inform before you enforce. Split is preparing cameras with automatic number-plate recognition against illegal parking that blocks buses, pavements and crossings, starting at 7 of 28 priority sites. Between December 2024 and March 2025, the city surveyed police, transport and parking companies, city staff and others. 93% of the 14 police respondents expected cameras to improve safety significantly. Almost all respondents from the transport and parking companies saw cameras as effective, but only with stricter enforcement, higher fines and frequent controls. City staff called education campaigns critical for public acceptance of video surveillance, and district council representatives felt left out of decisions. At a World Café and a public roundtable in May 2025, the main recommendation was clear: before installing cameras, run public information campaigns that explain what is happening and why. Stakeholders also asked for a well-communicated pilot phase and transparency about data protection, privacy rules and the legal basis. The city agreed to start with a pilot zone and to explain camera placement, data privacy and the rules. As of May 2026, procurement was still being finalised after an appeal, and the cameras were not yet operating.

Trikala: the police helped design the alerts. Trikala installed 22 sensors on bike lanes that detect illegal parking and send real-time alerts to the Municipal Police through an app. The police took part in all engagement activities and agreed to use the app during the pilot. The city found that engaging the police early was essential to understand their operational needs and co-design the alert service. It also concluded that infrastructure alone is not enough: consistent, visible enforcement, education and communication about the purpose of the measure were needed too.


Trikala: the app that alerts the Municipal Police when a sensor detects a vehicle parked in a bike lane.
Trikala: the app that alerts the Municipal Police when a sensor detects a vehicle parked in a bike lane.

Liberec: monitoring for planning as well as enforcement. Liberec runs a camera and sensor system that monitors illegal parking and vehicle movements in a housing estate. It began by checking residents' concerns about illegal parking. The data, analysed with the Czech Technical University in Prague, supports both enforcement and decisions on parking rules and the use of public space. The system was running steadily as of May 2026. The city's 2025 plan named a risk: responsibility for parking is split across municipal departments. Its answer was closer alignment between stakeholders.

Helsinki: no leverage, no participation. A 2025 pilot to monitor e-scooter parking assumed that operators would join, but they did not commit. Because e-scooter services in Helsinki were not tendered, neither the city nor Forum Virium Helsinki could require them to take part. Sensors were installed, but the pilot did not reach its main objectives. A new pilot, launched in May 2026, uses computer vision that counts scooters inside and outside parking zones while respecting privacy; results will come in D7.1. New micromobility licences, in force since early 2026, give cities more tools on e-scooter parking.


Practical relevance

Do

  • Run public information campaigns before cameras start working (Split).

  • Start with a well-communicated pilot zone rather than the whole city (Split).

  • Be open about where cameras are, how data is protected and what the legal basis is (Split).

  • Involve the police from the design stage, and design alerts around how they work (Trikala).

  • Combine technology with visible enforcement, education and physical measures (Trikala, Split).

  • Use the data for planning too, not only for fines (Liberec).

  • Agree early which department is responsible for what (Liberec).

Avoid

  • Leaving out groups who feel excluded, such as district councils (Split).

  • Expecting sensors or cameras to change behaviour on their own (Trikala).

  • Building a pilot on companies' voluntary participation when you cannot require it (Helsinki).

Conditions for transfer: camera enforcement in public space needs approvals and data protection checks that differ by country. In Split, the Ministry of Interior must approve the system, and it must follow GDPR and national data protection law.


Publication details

Article by THINGS, based on ELABORATOR deliverables D5.2, Lighthouse Cities Implementation Final Report (Work Package 5, July 2026), edited by Merja Penttinen, Anu Tuominen and Johannes Mesimäki (VTT); D6.1, Follower Cities Initial Implementation Report (Work Package 6, July 2025), including its Split consultation annex, and D6.3, Follower Cities Final Implementation Report (Work Package 6, July 2026), status as of May 2026, both edited by Juraj Vertlberg and Sanja Ševrović (FPZ); and D3.6, Twinning inception, replication plans and technical definitions of the Follower cities interventions (May 2025, revised August 2025, EIRA). All public.


Related


Disclaimer: The content of this article may be updated or changed, and this page will be updated if it does.

Full materials

Share this page:

Stay in touch!

Sign up to our mailing list to receive exclusive access to our newsletter and stay up to date with the latest project news and events.

Thanks for submitting!

Elaborator logo
  • LinkedIn
  • X

© 2023 Elaborator

Crafted with ♥️ by Threerooms

Co-funded EU logo

Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are however those of the author(s) only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or CINEA. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them.

Civitas-Logo
EU-Mission-Logo

ELABORATOR is part of the CIVITAS Initiative and contributes to the goals of the EU Mission: Climate-Neutral and Smart Cities

UKRI logo [W].png

UKRI supports UK participants with grant numbers 10078745 (iRAP ) and 10069203 (UBRIS)

bottom of page