top of page
grad-purple-blue.png

Approvals, permits and procurement: what slowed cities down

Methodology

Training

Intervention

Tool

Data

Study

Use case

THINGS, based on the ELABORATOR Lighthouse and Follower city reports

Overview

The lesson in one sentence: approvals, permits and procurement need as much planning as the technical design, because they decided the timing of many ELABORATOR interventions.

The Lighthouse cities found that interventions moved more slowly when approval processes were complex, even when the idea itself was sound. The Follower cities named procurement delays as one of their most common obstacles.


Highlights

Where time was lost

  • Issy-les-Moulineaux: the national road safety agency took more than 7 months (March to November 2024) to approve the light-emitting cycle-lane marking.

  • Helsinki: the tram-crossing warning took well over a year from planning to installation. The city had to choose the site, give permission and support the installation.

  • Zaragoza: sensors needed approval from several city departments at once. The installation window passed and the data was lost.

  • Trikala: the park-and-ride sites were revised several times. The city notes that such interventions need a lot of time and coordination for permits.

  • Split: the camera system was still in procurement in May 2026, including an appeal.

  • Ioannina: the city first had to prepare its own rules for shared micromobility before buying e-bikes.

Where time was saved

  • Zaragoza, Romareda: the full street design was formally approved in advance, so works can start as soon as the stadium works allow.

  • Zaragoza, tram crossing: agreeing early who owned what (city or tram operator) avoided delays. A quick, low-cost sound warning was installed while the bigger redesign went through approval.

  • Follower cities: phased planning helped them keep moving when one part was delayed.


Practical relevance

Do

  • Find the right people to talk to early, especially where many institutions are involved (Issy-les-Moulineaux).

  • Start permits well before the planned date, and coordinate early with all departments involved (Zaragoza).

  • Agree who owns what at the start when work spans different owners (Zaragoza).

  • Start with quick, low-cost steps while complex changes are approved (Zaragoza).

  • Build flexibility into plans, so they can be adjusted if the context changes (Zaragoza).

Avoid

  • Timing data collection or works so tightly that one late approval stops them, with no backup (Zaragoza).

  • Waiting for every component to be ready before starting anything (Zaragoza; Follower cities).

  • Planning a purchase before the rules that allow it exist (Ioannina).


Publication details

Article by THINGS, based on ELABORATOR deliverables D5.2, Lighthouse Cities Implementation Final Report (Work Package 5, July 2026, edited by VTT), and D6.3, Follower Cities Final Implementation Report (Work Package 6, July 2026, edited by FPZ). Both public.


Related


Disclaimer: The content of this article may be updated or changed, and this page will be updated if it does.

Full materials

Share this page:

Stay in touch!

Sign up to our mailing list to receive exclusive access to our newsletter and stay up to date with the latest project news and events.

Thanks for submitting!

Elaborator logo
  • LinkedIn
  • X

© 2023 Elaborator

Crafted with ♥️ by Threerooms

Co-funded EU logo

Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are however those of the author(s) only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or CINEA. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them.

Civitas-Logo
EU-Mission-Logo

ELABORATOR is part of the CIVITAS Initiative and contributes to the goals of the EU Mission: Climate-Neutral and Smart Cities

UKRI logo [W].png

UKRI supports UK participants with grant numbers 10078745 (iRAP ) and 10069203 (UBRIS)

bottom of page