top of page
grad-purple-blue.png

Need-gap template: from today's problem to concrete actions

Methodology

Training

Intervention

Tool

Data

Study

Use case

Vitaly Fedosov, Anshul Jain (THINGS)

Overview

A need-gap analysis compares the current state of an area with the state you want to reach, explains why there is a gap, and turns that into actions. All twelve ELABORATOR Lighthouse and Follower cities used this template to improve and prioritise their proposed interventions.


Highlights

How to fill it in

Fill in one table per intervention, one row per indicator. Download the template with the button at the end of this page, or copy the table below.

Indicator

Current state (from)

Desired future state (to)

Gap and root cause

Possible actions

What you measure

Where it is today, with a number if possible

Where you want it to be, and by when

The difference, and why it exists

What you will do, with a target

  1. Current state. Pick a few important indicators. For each, write a short conclusion from your research, your talks with stakeholders and existing data, with a number if possible.

  2. Desired future state. For the same indicators, describe the goal. Make it specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound.

  3. Gap and root cause. Compare the two and describe the gap simply, with a number or percentage. Then explain the reason for it.

  4. Possible actions. Use the root cause to choose actions that are straightforward, realistic and measurable.

Finish with recommendations on how to improve the intervention.


Example from the template

  • Current state: "Only 1 old playground, however 100 families with kids live in this area"

  • Desired state: "2 playgrounds for small kids and 1 big for teens in 2025"

  • Gap and root cause: "90%. There are no good playgrounds for small kids and teens. This area was mostly industrial for many years"

  • Actions: "Engage local business to support the development of the playgrounds in spring 2025"; "Build one new playground for teens in summer 2025"


Example from Milan

For its Olympic routes, Milan found that several intersections had architectural barriers and low quality. The root cause: the historic centre has narrow streets, stone paving and little room for pavements. The action: transform 39 intersections, giving more space to vulnerable road users and active mobility, and adding greenery where possible.


Practical relevance

Use the template when you know the problem but not yet the right intervention, or to check whether a proposed intervention addresses the real cause. The guidance adds two tips:

  • Talk to people first. Map your stakeholders, including vulnerable road users and "extreme users", who need much more or much less of something than typical users.

  • Reach out widely. Usually only about 10% of people invited will take part.


Publication details

Based on ELABORATOR deliverable D3.2, Feasibility and Action Plans – Final (Work Package 3, December 2024), edited by Vitaly Fedosov with Anshul Jain (THINGS). Dissemination level: public.


Related


Disclaimer: The content of this article may be updated or changed, and this page will be updated if it does.

Full materials

Share this page:

Stay in touch!

Sign up to our mailing list to receive exclusive access to our newsletter and stay up to date with the latest project news and events.

Thanks for submitting!

Elaborator logo
  • LinkedIn
  • X

© 2023 Elaborator

Crafted with ♥️ by Threerooms

Co-funded EU logo

Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are however those of the author(s) only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or CINEA. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them.

Civitas-Logo
EU-Mission-Logo

ELABORATOR is part of the CIVITAS Initiative and contributes to the goals of the EU Mission: Climate-Neutral and Smart Cities

UKRI logo [W].png

UKRI supports UK participants with grant numbers 10078745 (iRAP ) and 10069203 (UBRIS)

bottom of page